Hi, I’m Calli
Welcome! If you enjoy your visit, be sure to follow me:
Oh My Stars!
Canning Day Quilt

Pie Baking Tips

With Thanksgiving just a few days away, I’m sure there are more than a few of you out there getting ready to bake pie this week.  I have 30 people for dinner this year and I have been debating which pies to make and how many of each.

My list looks like this right now:

I know, there are no fancy pies on the list, just my tried and true favorites.  I may top one of the pumpkin pies with a fun and unusual topping, but mostly I’m sticking with what my family loves.  There is something comforting about these delicious old-fashioned pies on the very traditional day of Thanksgiving.

Since my oven will be full of turkey on Thanksgiving Day, I will be making the pies with my girls on Wednesday.  We will be watching/listening to movies and baking to our heart content.

Here’s a few tips that might make your pie making easier.

  • Give yourself plenty of time. Pie is one of those things that just can’t be rushed.
  • Cut in the fats and flour by hand, either with a pastry cutter or with your hands. My mom once tried to shortcut this process with her food processor.  Though she only pulsed the ingredients together, my brother-in-law asked her, as he ate his pie, “What happened to the crust?”  It just wasn’t as flaky or tender.
  • Make sure your fat of choice (lard, butter or shortening) is very cold. Cold fat = flaky crust.  My mom taught me to measure my lard and put it in the freezer for the 10 minutes it takes me to measure and sift the dry ingredients.
  • Don’t dump all the cold liquid into your pie at once. The amount needed really depends on things like humidity and your flour.  If your crust seems right, stop.  You may even need more than the recipe calls for occasionally.
  • When making a pre-baked crust for a cream filled pie, be sure to pierce the crust all over with a fork. This prevents the crust from shrinking in the oven.  With the recipe I use, I’ve never found the need for pie weights.  It can also help to chill your crust before baking to prevent shrinkage.  If you do need pie weights, you don’t need to buy them- just line your pie with foil and fill with dry beans or rice.
  • You can make and pre-bake the crusts for cream pies several days before you need them. Let your crusts cool completely and cover gently with a piece of foil.  Put them in a cool dry spot until you fill them.
  • Since cream pie filling is made on the stove top, I make the cream pie fillings on Thanksgiving morning. That still gives plenty of cooling time in the refrigerator, but ensures the pies are fresh.
  • One tip for a banana cream pie: I slice the bananas on the pie when I serve them. That way they don’t go brown, and taste fresh.
  • When putting the top on a double crust pie, I like to use a small cookie cutter to cut a fun shape (acorn, heart or scalloped circle) from the center of the pie as a vent and for decoration. I cut it out while I still have the crust on my pastry frame.  Then I roll the crust halfway on the rolling pin, center my cutout and roll the top crust into place.
  • Before rolling the top crust into place, I dip my finger in water and run it around the bottom crust. That little bit of moisture helps seal the two crusts together.
  • I also love to brush my top crust with a little evaporated milk, half/half or even milk, then sprinkle it with granulated sugar. It makes a lovely golden crust.
  • Make pie a tradition. This past week, my mom and I taught a pie class for about 50 people.  Together we made around 100 pies.  It was epic.  And fun.  One of the women there makes pie with her sisters and sister-in-laws each Thanksgiving.  She said they all make their favorites and they make around 20 pies together.  It’s something they all love and look forward to. Some of my fondest memories of childhood are of making pie with my mom.  I remember stirring the fillings, helping flute the edges of the pie, and best of all baking and eating cinnamon pie scraps.  It’s a tradition I’ve carried on with my girls and one we love and look forward to each year.
  • If you have a good pie baker in the family, make a date and bake pie together. Those family pie traditions are treasures.  Several years before my husband’s 90 year old grandmother passed away, my husband went to her home and baked pies with her for Thanksgiving.  He took notes as they baked.  That memory is priceless to him as are the tips she shared (that now I use).

I’ve shared a tutorial on Perfect Pie Crust here and here.  The tutorials are one way to make pie, but there are many ways to make a great pie crust.  It’s more of a method that can be used with many recipes.  The recipe I use most often, the recipe from my mom, is a fabulous crust that is tender, flaky and easy to make.

This Thanksgiving seems especially poignant to me.  My heart has been so full of gratitude.  I look forward to all the lovely moments this week of preparation and spending time with my loved ones on Thanksgiving day.

Last but not least, I’ll share a few fun quotes I found in preparation for the pie class we taught.

“Good apple pies are a considerable part of our domestic happiness” ~Jane Austen

“When you die, if you get a choice between going to regular heaven or pie heaven, choose pie heaven. It might be a trick, but if it’s not, mmmmmmmm, boy.” – Jack Handy

“One little thing can revive a guy/ and that is a homemade rhubarb pie/ Serve it up nice and hot/ maybe things aren’t as bad as you thought.” ~ A Prairie Home Companion

“Cut my pie into four pieces, I don’t think I could eat eight.” – Yogi Berra (Thanks Judy!)

“In the childhood memories of every good cook, there’s a large kitchen, a warm stove, a simmering pot, and a mom.”  Barbara Costikyan

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Google Buzz
  • Yahoo! Buzz

9 Responses to “Pie Baking Tips”

  • My grandma taught me to bake pies when I was in college. I’m so glad that I took the time to learn from her. Now, I bake the pies for Thanksgiving every year. I’ve been doing that for almost ten years now. I look forward to when my kids are older and I can have them help.

    My pies this year will be apple (crumb top), caramel pumpkin pecan (a nice combo of pumpkin and pecan from Better Homes & Gardens cookbook), and coconut cream. I’ll be getting the pie crust ready tomorrow and make the pies Wednesday and Thursday for the cream pie.

  • Alexa:

    Excellent tips, all! I’ve tried most of them, so I second them. As for the hand-mixing, it doesn’t more than an extra minute to not use the food processor. And you get that time back by not having to wash the food processor.

    Another use of cookie cutters in top crusts is to make a non-woven lattice top replacement. Roll the dough out on wax paper and then cut out a whole bunch of little shapes. Flip the paper and dough over onto the filling and peel back the paper. I like using turkey shapes at Thanksgiving. or mixing it up and cutting pumpkin shapes out of an apple crust. My favorite pie cookbook, Pie, by Ken Haedrich, suggests putting a vent near the rim, so you can better see if the filling is bubbling up. I’ll make that a tiny cut-out on each 1/8 or 1/6, which gives you a handy slicing guide later.

    You can save all those little cut-outs and put them on other pies or brush them with milk and sprinkle with sugar for sparkly, not so sweet cookies. I like to use Sugar in the Raw, since it has larger crystals that don’t melt into the dough.

  • Holly:

    These are wonderful tips! I grew up with butter crust for pies, so that always tastes the best to me. My husband grew up with lard crusts. Our differing preferences are a great excuse to make twice as many pies as we might otherwise! This year we’re making two apple pies, a pumpkin pie, and a cranberry/pear cobbler. Although that chocolate pecan pie of yours sounds delectable – maybe we’ll find room in the kitchen to make that one, too!

    Your post reminded me of summers as a child, when my sister and I would make an apple pie every year from the very very tart apples that grew in our backyard. I’d forgotten all about that. We haven’t made a pie together since she left for college so many decades ago – wouldn’t it be fun to bring back that tradition?

  • diane:

    does anyone know of a recipe for a carmel pie? many years ago there was a sandwich shop/deli type restaurant in town and their specialty was this wonderful carmel pie. The man who owned and ran the restaurant told a story about how he had gotten the recipe from an old woman who shared it with him many years before. He wouldn’t give the recipe though. It was creamy sort of like pudding consistency, but tasted and appeared exactly like carmel from the inside of a chocolate covered carmel candy. It wasn’t that sort of sticky consistency like candy though, it cut easily and held its shape. It was wonderful and i sure would love a recipe if anyone knows of one.

    • Claudia Cantrell:

      I wonder if it’s a recipe for butterscotch pie that you’re talking about. It’s a wonderful cream pie made from scratch. I remember the Betty Crocker cookbook having a recipe many years ago. Try looking online for a recipe for butterscotch cream pie. Yummy!

    • Dayna:

      Here’s my great grandma’s recipe for butterscotch pie (it’s a Thanksgiving favorite in our family):
      6 c whole milk (must be whole milk for pie to set up)
      1 c flour
      2 c brown sugar
      pinch salt
      5 egg yolks, beaten
      1 t vanilla
      1 T real butter
      Heat milk over medium heat. In separate bowl, mix flour and sugar together, then add to milk, stirring constantly till thickened (be patient, it takes around 20 minutes). Add remaining ingredients and pour into prebaked pie shells. Serve with homemade whipped cream…heaven!

  • Thanks for this! Nothing like help in the kitchen. ;)

  • Jennifer:

    Thanks for all the tips Calli! I am just getting ready to make my crusts (and watch Little Women with my girls) and I’m wondering what you think about 9.5 instead of a 9″ pie plate? will I not have enough filling? should I find some 9″ or just go with what i have? thanks!

Leave a Reply


Virtual Quilting Bee